• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
    • Editorial Staff
      • Bryan Strawser, Editor in Chief, Strife
      • Dr Anna B. Plunkett, Founder, Women in Writing
      • Strife Journal Editors
      • Strife Blog Editors
      • Strife Communications Team
      • Senior Editors
      • Series Editors
      • Copy Editors
      • Strife Writing Fellows
      • Commissioning Editors
      • War Studies @ 60 Project Team
      • Web Team
    • Publication Ethics
    • Open Access Statement
  • Archive
  • Series
  • Strife Journal
  • Strife Policy Papers
    • Strife Policy Papers: Submission Guidelines
    • Vol 1, Issue 1 (June 2022): Perils in Plain Sight
  • Contact us
  • Submit to Strife!

Strife

The Academic Blog of the Department of War Studies, King's College London

  • Announcements
  • Articles
  • Book Reviews
  • Call for Papers
  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Strife Policy Papers
    • Strife Policy Papers: Submission Guidelines
    • Vol 1, Issue 1 (June 2022): Perils in Plain Sight
You are here: Home / Archives for Refugee Crisis

Refugee Crisis

Strife Review – Khaled Hosseini, Sea Prayer: Refugees, Storytelling and the importance of Human Dignity

October 3, 2018 by Anna Plunkett

By Anna Plunkett

Khaled Hosseini (Credit Image: UNHCR/Paul Wu)

 

“I have heard it said that we are the uninvited.

We are the unwelcome.

We should take our misfortune elsewhere.

But I hear your mother’s voice,

Over the tide,

And she whispers in my ear,

‘Oh, but if they saw, my darling.

Even half of what you have.

If only they saw.

They would say kinder things, surely.”

-Hosseini, Sea Prayer 

 

Like many others, it was Khaled Hosseini’s novels that brought the vibrancy of conflict alive for me. His books have enraptured thousands, detailing lives under oppressive regimes, insecurity, and conflict. He has detailed the normalisation of violence, the varying levels and stages of fear, and the wide-ranging uncertainty. Though, perhaps more importantly, he’s illustrated the moments of normalcy, joy, sadness, and tenderness that are part of life, even in extenuating circumstances.  His stories focus around the family unit and how the developments, challenges, and changes to these fundamental ties transcend the cacophony of chaos that conflict brings.

As such, I was thrilled when, as part of the Literature and Spoken Word programme at the Southbank Centre, Khaled Hosseini presented his latest work – Sea Prayer.  A move away from the mountains of Afghanistan that first inspired the Afghan-American doctor to turn his talents to writing. Sea Prayer was inspired by the death of Alan Kurdi who was found washed up on the beaches of Turkey. The image of the three-year-old boy became one of the most iconic images of the Syrian War in 2015 after the boat he and his family were fleeing on capsized just minutes after leaving the shore. The illustrated novel pays homage to those who lost their lives whilst crossing the Mediterranean and narrates the stories of those who survived.

For ninety minutes, Hosseini held the stage in the cavernous Royal Festival Hall speaking to an audience and an interviewer, Razia Iqbal, who were equally rapt and charmed. Born in Afghanistan in 1965, he left in 1976 when his family relocated to Paris for his father’s diplomatic career but was unable to return after the 1979 Soviet invasion. Hosseini spoke about his first-hand experience of becoming a refugee – watching the invasion on TV in Paris as a teenager and realising that his life was about to change, dramatically. From there, he relocated to the US, and attended school whilst speaking no English, and watched his parents struggle to understand and overcome the challenges they now faced in a completely alien situation. It is easy to see the links he draws between his own life and those of his characters.

Hosseini delivered his message clearly. He stressed the importance of storytelling in understanding and overcoming the challenges of the refugee experience. As many qualitative researchers will attest, figures and statistics can miss vital details and experiences that need to be considered when understanding social and political phenomena. Hosseini adds to this, noting how the use of statistics has distanced and dehumanised the refugee plight whereas personal stories can help to overcome the misconceptions and misunderstandings around such complex issues.  Storytelling, in Hosseini’s eyes can make seemingly inconceivable situations and choices, such as putting your loved ones on a boat that you know may not make it to the other side, understandable and relatable.

Additionally, drawing heavily on his time as a UNHCR Goodwill Ambassador since 2006 and his trips to Uganda, Lebanon, and Sicily, Hosseini also spoke about the importance of human dignity and why this should challenge our current thinking about the refugee experience. Engaging with numerous refugees and communities who are at different stages in their journey to finding a new home, Hosseini noted three essential rights that he believes are critical when considering the refugee experience: the sanctity of families; the right to asylum; and the right to human dignity.

The first is clearly an issue close to Hosseini as can be seen throughout his work. On the importance of family, he joked that “privacy was another word for being lonely” and family, as he was sure every Afghan in the audience could attest, was everything. Thus, as he rightly identifies, refugees need to be respected – families should not and cannot be separated. The precedent that they can is not only a dangerous one but one that can have disastrous consequences.

The right to asylum is protected under the UN Declaration of Human Rights under article 14. However, as the mobilisation of populations has increased recently and especially since the refugee crisis has hit along the Mediterranean’s shores, this human right has increasingly come under threat. With borders closing to such asylum seekers across regions previously welcoming to refugees, new solutions need to be found.  Hosseini remains resolute – he believes that this is not a problem for refugees and asylum seekers alone. He avers that we, as a society, must own and be responsible for guaranteeing this right.

The last of these rights, the right to human dignity, is probably the most under threat among them. With growing dehumanisation of migrants, the rights of these people are often forgotten. People fleeing conflict, in fear of their lives, risking the ‘vessels of desperation’[1] have become caught in a system that rarely provides the materials or opportunities for dignity and purpose. It does not have to be this way – Hosseini acknowledged alternative, progressive strategies being piloted in Uganda where South Sudanese refugees receive plots of land in local communities three days after entering the country.

Overall, the book is a slim volume that is exactly what it says on the tin – a prayer from a father to the seas for safe passage of his precious cargo. The short verses bring work in harmony with Dan Williams’ beautiful artwork to bring the hauntingly sad story to life. Hosseini attempts to capture the essence of the refugee’s plight and the loss that comes with it – it is a story Hosseini admits hearing told to him time and again by refugees during his visits with UNHCR. Hosseini noted that storytelling invites listeners to perceive the world from a plurality of perspectives and this, in all its forms, helps overcome the misconceptions and instead build communal understanding. Storytelling may be the bridge over misunderstandings between the two communities – refugee and the local recipient community. However, there is a social obligation by us all that must be realised – the refugee crisis does not belong to refugees. It belongs to us all as a society. We must improve our collective action to ensure that human dignity is guaranteed to all people, including those refugees who so clearly deserve it.

 

Khaled Hosseini presented Sea Prayer in conversation with Razia Iqbal at the Southbank Centre on the 4th September 2018. Sea Prayer was released for sale in the UK on the 30th August 2018, and in the US on the 18th September 2018. It was written in collaboration with the UNHCR and illustrated by Dan Williams.  

 


Anna is a doctoral researcher in the Department of War Studies, King’s College London. She received her BA in Politics and Economics from the University of York, before receiving a scholarship to continue her studies at York with an MA in Post-War Recovery. She was the recipient of the Guido Galli Award for her MA dissertation. Her primary interests include conflict and democracy at the sub-national level, understanding how minor conflicts impact democratic realisation within quasi-post conflict states. Her main area of focus is Burma’s ethnic borderlands and ongoing conflicts within the region. She has previously worked as a human rights researcher focusing on military impunity in Burma and has conducted work on evaluating Bosnia’s post-war recovery twenty years after the Dayton Peace Accords. You can follow her in Twitter @AnnaBPlunkett


Notes:

[1] Hosseini in conversation about the boats used to cross the Mediterranean at the Southbank Centre, 4th September 2018.

 


Image Source:

Banner: http://www.unhcr.org/khaled-hosseini.html

Image 2: https://www.bloomsbury.com/uk/sea-prayer-9781526602718/


 

Filed Under: Blog Article Tagged With: Book Review, conflict, feature, Refugee Crisis

The Rohingya Need More International Protection

October 24, 2017 by William McPherson

By William McPherson

Displaced Rohingya people in Rakhine State, Myanmar (Source: Foreign and Commonwealth Office, via Wikimedia Commons)

 

In August/September 2017, around 500,000 Rohingya Muslims fled to Bangladesh, trying to escape a violent crackdown by the Myanmar military. The latest round of violence towards the Rohingya people began at the end of August — after the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) militant group attacked and killed 12 Myanmar security personnel. There have been reports from fleeing refugees of elite Myanmar soldiers killing or violently forcing Rohingya Muslims from their homes, stealing and burning properties as they move from village to village.

The Myanmar civilian government, led by State Counsellor (Prime Minister) Aung San Suu Kyi, and the military leadership have rejected the accusation of targeting civilians, saying the army is just conducting anti-terrorism raids against militant groups. As human rights groups, the media, and international observers are unable to gain access into Rakhine state, where most of the violence has taken place, verifying the claims and reports been made either by the fleeing Rohingya Muslims or the military has been impossible. The only evidence are photos and videos from refugees in camps in Bangladesh and satellite images of burning villages.

The Military operation in August/September 2017 has shown how weak Ms Suu Kyi is when dealing with internal security issues, as the civilian government does not have control over the military and police. The real power is still in the hands of the generals, not the civilian government. As such, the military are the perpetrating actors in committing these human right abuses — and more emphasis on their actions is required, rather than criticism toward Ms Suu Kyi. Even if personally Ms Suu Kyi, a former human rights and democracy campaigner, might want to advocate for the protection of the Rohingya Muslims, she seems to lack political, military and public support.

Although Ms Suu Kyi’s National League for Democracy (NLD) won the 2015 elections, the constitution bestows real power to the military, who are allocated 25 percent of seats in parliament, and also are not under the authority of the civilian government. The NLD have to be causes when dealing with such a delicate issue as minority groups, as apart from the military dislike, there is also hatred for Muslims by a majority Buddhist population. In recent decades there has been an increase in Buddhist nationalist groups, such as the Ma Ba Tha, who have fuelled tensions between the two communities since its founding in 2013. With no authority over the military and a hatred by some of the Buddhist population, Ms Suu Kyi has been balancing between trying to enact reforms on the one hand and appease the military and nationalist groups on the other.

To make the crisis even more direr for the Rohingya Muslims, the latter do not hold citizenship rights neither in Myanmar (where they are called Bengali Muslims) nor in Bangladesh. In essence, the one million Rohingya Muslims are stateless. In Myanmar, Buddhist nationalists — who view them as Bengali migrants — have persecuted this group for decades. Without recognition or rights, they have become a forgotten ethnic group, with limited recourse to basic healthcare, education, and employment.

Since the latest military crackdown, human rights groups and the United Nations (UN) have condemned the violence and called for the halting of security operations against the Rohingya Muslims. The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Zeid Raad Al Hussein, has said that the security operation against the Rohingya Muslims ‘seems a textbook example of ethnic cleansing’. The UN Secretary-General, Antonio Guterres, has also spoken of a need to halt the violent military operations.

At a recent United Nations Security Council (UNSC) meeting, member states further condemned the military for the violent crackdown, with French President Emmanuel Macron calling the actions of the military as ‘genocide’. U.S Vice President Mike Pence also condemned the military violence and called for the UN and UNSC ‘to take strong and swift action to bring this crisis to an end — and give hope and help to the Rohingya people in their hour of need.’ There has been condemnation by some world leaders towards the Myanmar government and military, but no joint agreement on how the international community could place further pressure on these institutions.

If Ms Suu Kyi is correct in her claim that the military have stopped ‘clearance operations,’ the current situation in the region will hopefully stabilise, allowing refugees to return. The issue now is how the international community and the Myanmar government can work together to prevent future violence and improve the lives of Rohingya Muslims.

In the near-term, the international community needs to place pressure, through the threat of economic sanctions or other embargos on both the civilian government and military, aimed at the immediate halt to the violent crackdown. There also needs to be an increased role for UN and other humanitarian agencies to assist the Myanmar government in its responsibility to protect. This could be undertaken by acting as a mediator between the government and the Rohingya Muslims. An ideal situation would be an agreement between the Myanmar government/military and the international community to send a UN observer mission to Rakhine state to oversee the repatriation of returning refugees and the delivery of aid. The UN mission should also have the mandate to observe the military operations and report back to the UNSC on any human rights abuses.

The second way forward in dealing with the crisis is for the international community to work with the Myanmar government to carry out the recommendations of the Advisory Commission on Rakhine State. The Myanmar government-established commission, led by former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, outlines a list of recommendations to improve living conditions for Rohingya Muslims, including ending restrictions on citizenship, marriage, and freedom of movement; and improving health care and education. To undertake these recommendations by the commission, the Myanmar government has established a Committee for Implementation of the Recommendations on Rakhine State. In a statement released by the Myanmar President’s office, the committee has been given a list of duties: including, improving living condition, equal access to education and healthcare, and efforts to bring peace and security to the region. Many of the duties outlined by the government, do not specifically adhere to protecting or improving the lives of the persecuted Rohingya Muslims, just to the population in Rakhine state in general. As the Kofi Annan led commission’s recommendations were only released in August 2017, there has been no major reforms, except for the establishment of an implementation committee. So far the Myanmar government have indicated that the reforms will be conducted in-house, with a planned formation of an advisory commission, with international experts. These are all good steps, but the international community should be more involved in the implementing the recommended reforms.

These recommendations are the ideal process for preventing future violence and improving the lives of the Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar, although the military and its major international supporter, China, would likely block a UN observer mission. For instance, due to China’s national interest, they might block any UN-led mission in the case of objection by Myanmar military. Even the civilian government would be powerless to agree to an UN-led mission without the support of the military leadership.

In the short term, the only option available to the international community to protect Rohingya Muslims displaced in Myanmar and returning refugees is to monitor the situation from afar and continue to place pressure on the Myanmar government and military.  We will need to see if the civilian government has enough power and political will to effectively carry out the recommendations of the advisory commission.

As for the long term, if the situation for the Rohingya Muslims does not improve and they still face human right abuses and discrimination, the international community may require more forceful measures to put pressure on the Myanmar military. Even though sanctions on the military would lack China’s support, placing more unilateral embargoes by the U.S, European countries, and other states could be a measure to be considered.


William McPherson is a MA: International Relations and Security graduate from University of Westminster, London. He is interested in many topics within the field of international relations and security, but his main focus is on humanitarian intervention, and the Responsibility to Protect. He has previously worked in the defence and security sector, including an internship at Risk Intelligence Solutions (RIS), based in Perth, Australia.


Image sources: 

Image 1:   https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Displaced_Rohingya_people_in_Rakhine_State_(8280610831)_(cropped).jpg

Feature image:   https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/07/Displaced_Rohingya_people_in_Rakhine_State_%288280610831%29.jpg

Filed Under: Blog Article Tagged With: feature, Myanmar, Refugee Crisis, South East Asia

Footer

Contact

The Strife Blog & Journal

King’s College London
Department of War Studies
Strand Campus
London
WC2R 2LS
United Kingdom

blog@strifeblog.org

 

Recent Posts

  • Climate-Change and Conflict Prevention: Integrating Climate and Conflict Early Warning Systems
  • Preventing Coup d’Étas: Lessons on Coup-Proofing from Gabon
  • The Struggle for National Memory in Contemporary Nigeria
  • How UN Support for Insider Mediation Could Be a Breakthrough in the Kivu Conflict
  • Strife Series: Modern Conflict & Atrocity Prevention in Africa – Introduction

Tags

Afghanistan Africa Brexit China Climate Change conflict counterterrorism COVID-19 Cybersecurity Cyber Security Diplomacy Donald Trump drones Elections EU feature France India intelligence Iran Iraq ISIL ISIS Israel ma Myanmar NATO North Korea nuclear Pakistan Politics Russia security strategy Strife series Syria terrorism Turkey UK Ukraine United States us USA women Yemen

Licensed under Creative Commons (Attribution, Non-Commercial, No Derivatives) | Proudly powered by Wordpress & the Genesis Framework